8th Situpa Chökyi Jungnay

1704 - 1774

Chökyi Jungnay became an exceptional scholar and artist who worked for the benefit of all by taking every opportunity to make his knowledge available to as many people as possible in the form of works that remain important until today. He established the famous Derge printing press, close to where he founded Palpung Monastery, which became the main seat of the Situpas. 

Chökyi Jungnay was always close to the people, traveled a great deal and spoke several languages.

STORY

Seeing the hypocrisy that existed in many monasteries and the greed of even some teachers, Tai Situpa deplored those who violated their vows and who sacrificed compassion in favor of exploiting others. He explicitly expressed his disgust in a song. Verses published in “The Rain of Wisdom” include:

 

“You, Karmapa, are the refuge and protector of the world,

The guide, more excellent than all the victorious ones.

Is there time now for you to look at us,

A flock of insensitive devourers of gifts?

This is the time of the darkest of the dark age.

If you Kagyüs would consider the activity of us in samsara

And not protect us from the abyss of bad karma,

Your great kindness would be a lie.

 

Kye ma! The dharmas of samsara are futile.

Especially, the activity of the dark age is futile.

In particular, hypocritical practitioners are futile.

Especially, charlatan gurus are futile.

Formerly, I was deceived by grasping at these as meaningful.

Your disciples also are confused and grasp at these as meaningful. (…)

 

These days, some bodhisattvas

Receive all exalted and common people with a smile,

And reward the wealthy and powerful with a meal.

They tame those with resistance through deception.

They proclaim their freedom from joy and sorrow, passion and aggression.

They also proclaim their unbiased generosity.

 

Such proclamations become so widespread

That first, they who do not know pretend to know.

Secondly, they who are unaccomplished pretend to be accomplished.

Thirdly, their innermost mind aims for wealth.

Fourthly, they con and swindle.

Fifthly, they blaze like fire with passion and aggression.

 

These people are completely covered up and so hidden

That they are not seen even by insightful people.

They lure people’s minds with the iron hook of material things,

And the three gates are smashed into dust.

If what you say is true, O mighty lord of the Shakyas,

What will result from such deeds in the end? (…)

 

Their establishing the teachings actually destroys the teachings.

They are obsessed with their fear of sickness and death.

They perform retreats by making themselves comfortable and sleeping on the sly,

While making future plans of passion, aggression, and delusion.“

 

… and he added,

 

“Although I have not accomplished great benefit for the teachings and beings,

I desire to dedicate whatever little merit I have accumulated

For the welfare of the teachings and beings.

This is not just talk or lip service.

I wonder, ‘Do the lord victorious ones give thought to me?’

In the midst of the gathering of the deceitful who support one lie with another lie,

I do not add on to this chain of charlatanisms.

As I have no great entertainment of immediate diversions,

My burden of evil karma is very light;

This is the kindness of the lord guru.“

 

After his fourth journey in Tibet, the 8th Situpa visited Nepal again on pilgrimage and was highly honored there. Once, after a debate with a great Hindu scholar from Kashmir, it was proclaimed by the local Hindus that Situpa must have been blessed by the Lord Shiva, since that was the only way he could have achieved such insight and learning.

At the age of 50, according to the Tibetan medical texts Chökyi Jungnay made the famous medicine pill, "Moon Nectar Pill". Once, he manufactured a kind of special pills which grew on their own and spilled out of the bottle. Then, for our minds, surprisingly, the pills became all kinds of Buddhas. This was the beginning of many more special effects that Chökyi Jungnay produced. He became a skilled physician and a master of Tibetan medicine. He composed and wrote medical books which guide practitioners until today.

Key Transmissions

Received Transmissions (an excerpt)

As for all future lineage holders the following four are the core transmissions of the Kagyü and later the Karma Kagyü Lineage:

  • Mahamudra
  • Six Teachings of Naropa (including Father, Mother and Non-Dual Tantras)
  • Path of Insight > Shinay/Lhaktong
  • Secret Path > Guru Yoga
  • Vajravarahi
  • Buddhist philosophies
  • Tara

 

Additional Given Transmissions (an excerpt)

  • Chökyi Jungnay painted a set of thangkhas of eight mahasiddhas using the style of Gadri school of painting.
  • He founded the famous Palpung monastery (1727), from then on the main seat of the Situpas.
  • Chökyi Jungnay revised texts of Kanjur, Tenjur of Derge transcript, and many other texts in order to make print plates of them; in cooperation with the Derge Printing House, he published the new versions.
  • He translated the Svayambhupurana, the legends of the Svayambhu stupa, into Tibetan.
  • Retrospectively, he is seen of one of the originators of the Rimé movement.
  • He was the first one who wrote down the hagiographies/biographies of the former Mahamudra lineage holders > The Garland of the Moon Water Crystal; thus, Situpa was the perfect forefather of this current project (it was later completed by Topga Rinpoche).

 

Additional Special Abilities

  • “Five mundane knowledges” > divine eye = the ability to see the demise and rebirth of beings according to their deeds, divine ear = the ability to hear heavenly and earthly sounds far and near, knowledge of other minds = the ability to know the thoughts and mental states of others, recollection of previous habitations, various supernatural powers
  • Indian local languages and Sanskrit, Nepali, Chinese languages and Mongol
  • astrology
  • painting, carving, printing
  • Commentary of Tibetan grammar (it’s still in use)
  • Tibetan medicine – master of Tibetan medicine and a skilled physician

 

  • Key-instructions how to conquer death
  • Fundamental Verses of the Middle Way (Mūlamādhyamakakārikā or Madhyamaka)
  • Mahamudra-Transmission in meditation/in a vision from Ratnamati in Southern India (where Ratnamati had lived)
  • Tripitaka-texts (Triple Basket)
  • Seventy Verses on Emptiness (Shunyatasapati)
  • Two Truths Doctrine - about relative and absolute level (= level with delusion and level without delusion)“
  • Six Collections on Reasoning (text)
  • Root Verses on the Middle Way, called "Discriminating Awareness"
  • Precious Garland
  • Refutation of Objections
  • Seventy Verses on Emptiness
  • Sutra Called “Finely Woven”
  • Sixty Verses of Reasoning
  • Collections of Praises (text)
  • Praise to the Sphere of Reality
  • Praise to the Deepest Truth
  • Praise to the Supramundane (Buddha)
  • Collections of Didactic Explanations (text)
  • A Commentary on (the Two) Bodhichittas
  • Selected text-collection of Sutras
  • Letter to a Friend
  • all Mahakali and Mahakala-Tantras
  • Guyhasamaja-Tantras

  • Della Santina, Peter: Causality and Emptiness: The Wisdom of Nāgārjuna, Singapore: Buddha Dharma Education Association, 2002
  • Garfield, Jay L. (1995), The Fundamental Wisdom of the Middle Way.Oxford: Oxford University Press
  • Garfield, Jay L. and Graham Priest (2003), “Nāgārjuna and the Limits of Thought”, Philosophy East and West 53 (January 2003): 1-21
  • Hopkins, Jeffrey: Buddhist Advice for Living and Liberation: Nāgārjuna’s Precious Garland, Ithaca, NY: Snow Lion, 199
  • Jones, Richard H. (2014): Nagarjuna: Buddhism's Most Important Philosopher, 2nd ed. New York: Jackson Square Books
  • Kalupahana, David J. (1986): The Philosophy of the Middle Way. Albany: SUNY Press
  • Lindtner, Christian (1982): Nagarjuniana: Studies in the Writings and Philosophy of Nāgārjuna Akademisk forlag
  • Murty, K. Satchidananda (1971), Nagarjuna. National Book Trust, New Delhi. 2nd edition: 1978
  • Ruegg, D. Seyfort (1981): The literature of the Madhyamaka school of philosophy in India (A History of Indian literature), Harrassowitz
  • Siderits, Mark and Shōryū Katsura, 2013: Nāgārjuna’s Middle Way. Mūlamadhyamakakārikā, Boston: Wisdom Publications
  • Tuck, Andrew P. (1990), Comparative Philosophy and the Philosophy of Scholarship: on the Western Interpretation of Nāgārjuna, Oxford: Oxford University Press
  • Walser, Joseph (2005), Nāgārjuna in Context: Mahāyāna Buddhism and Early Indian Culture. New York: Columbia University Press
  • Westerhoff, Jan (2009), Nāgārjuna's Madhyamaka. A Philosophical Introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press
https://www.shambala.com/nagarjuna-readers-guide https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/nagarjuna/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XbUzz0_Oy1k

Historical events at this time

1679 The Central Tibetan Ganden Phodrang government wanted to incorporate Ladakh into Tibet after it had thrown out the Gelugpas and claimed a kind of independence. With the assistance of the Kashmiri Mughals (Muslims), the Tibetan-Mongolian army was defeated in 1684. However, Ladakh, came under the influence of Kashmir. In 2019, finally, Ladakh was administratively disconnected from Jammu and Kashmir and became an Indian Union Territory.

1697 Tsangyang Gyatso, the 6th Dalai Lama (1683 – 1706) was enthroned. He had an unorthodox lifestyle (alcohol and women) an d became famous because of his love-songs and poetry. Actually, the 5th Dalai Lama's death has been kept secret for many years until the Potala-palace was completed in 1694. That's why the 6th Dalai Lama became 'official' only in 1697 when he was already a juvenile. At that point, as a boy in puberty, it was already too late for a strict education in a monastery.

1706 The Mongol Lhasang Khan dismissed the Dalai Lama as being illegitimate. He was deported to China; on the way there he died under mysterious circumstances after having been taken prisoner.

Invasion of the Dzungars (1717-1720)

1717 The Dzungars (a Mongolian tribe) invaded tibet. They wanted to take possession of the new-born Kelsang Gyatso, the 7th Dalai Lama (1708 – 1757), who was brought to the Kumbum-monastery near the former border to China. They conquered Lhasa, killed Lhasang Khan and established a reign of terror.
1719/20 Chinese troops chased the Dzungars out of Tibet and transformed Tibet to their protectorate.  

 

Ming / Manchu dynasty (1644-1911)

The influence of the Ming / Manchu dynasty started in Tibet in the end of the 17th century, when the Manchus aligned themselves with the Koshot-Mongols. They considered the Koshot-Mongols as custodians for their interests in terms of Tibet. We should not forget: The 6th Dalai Lama should be deported to China. In 1720 the Chinese instituted the 7th Dalai Lama as a ruler again after he was brought to Lhasa. 

Since the time of Karma Pakshi/Sakya Pandita there existed a so-called "priest-patron-relationship" between big Tibetan lamas and the Mongolian court (Yüan-dynasty). This continued - with interruptions - also during the Ming dynasty (King Yung Lo relocated the capitol from Najing to Beijing).

Later different emperors of the Ming-dynasties took on the custom. Buddhism was the main religion at the court in Beijing. Aside from it, the Confuzian teachings and Daoism equal ideologies existed. At that time, people in China  liked to speak of the "unity of three religions". Highly ranked lamas (Sakyas, Kagyüs and later Gelugpas) felt compelled again and again to pay the emperor a courtesy visit; among them several Karmapas up to the 12th Karmapa who in 1732 - together with the 8th Sharmapa - died in Beijing. The respective Manchu-emperors considered Tibet as a protectorate, interfered varyingly strong into their inner affairs, and until the beginning of the 20th century financed many monasteries there, including the livelihood of thousands, probably ten-thousands of monks.

The very important 8th Situpa Chökyi Nyungne (1700 - 1774), founder and abbott of the famous Palpung monastery in Eastern Tibet, was the last high-ranked Karma Kagyü Lama who visited Beijing around 1761. A couple of years later, Situ Rinpoche was invited again - already at old age - to travel to China. In 1774 he died on the way there. Afterwards the Chinese court turned more to the Gelugpas.

Without the Chinese backing, from a political perspective, the Karma Kagyü Lineage faced difficulties in Central Tibet throughout the late 18th and 19th century. Admittedly, the missing intervention brought many advantages for the spiritual quality of the Kagyü Lineage. (Thanks to the activity of the Rimey-movement under the influence of the great Jamgön Kongtrul Lodrö Thaye (1813 - 1899) and others the "old lineages" received a broad appreciation during the 19th century (which ran into danger to split up into many "valleys").

1723 and later The new Manchu emperor withdrew the Chinese garrisons from Lhasa, which led to a civil war. His troops returned shortly afterwards; either the rivals assassinated each other or many rebels, former Desis and their families etc. were executed or died through cruel tortures.
1728 The 7th Dalai Lama was a great scholar, a prolific writer and a poet. His collected works run seven volumes and contain numerous commentaries, liturgical works as well as many religious poems. He was exiled for seven years. The Chinese took over the power.
1728 – 1911 The Manchus reestablished a garrison in Lhasa; two resident Manchu officials, known as Ambans, were in charge of the garrison, as direct representatives of the Manchu emperor. This lasted until the fall of the Manchu dynasty in 1911.
1728 – 1747 Miwang Polhanas was the actual ruler of Tibet, supported by the Manchu emperor. 
1747 – 1750 Polhanas’ youngest son Gyumey Namgyal followed his father. He tried to get rid of the Chinese Ambans, that’s why he was killed. His striving for Tibetan independence ended in many more cruelties and a permanent residence of ambans.
1751 In January a Manchu officer came to Lhasa, together with troops, and restored the Chinese influence. The 7th Dalai Lama assumed temporal power. He appointed a Tibetan government and installed a council of ministers (Kashag).
1757 – 1777 After 7th Dalai Lama’s death, Demo Tulku Jampal Delek led the government affairs as the regent.
1777 – 1781 The 2nd regent took over office because the 20-year-old Dalai Lama said he was not yet fully trained.

 

Invasions of the Gurkhas (1788-1792)

Jamphel Gyatso, the 8th Dalai Lama (1758 – 1804) was enthroned in 1762, at age five at the Potala Palace in Lhasa. Regents managed Tibet's administration during his minority. He ruled Tibet independently from 1784 to 1790, but later relied on regents for governance. He established Norbulingka Park and Summer Palace on the outskirts of Lhasa, which became a summer residence for future Dalai Lamas. During his tenure, Tibet faced invasions by Gurkhas (Nepal). Qing dynasty troops intervened, driving back the invaders and stabilizing the region.
1788-1789 The first Nepal-Tibet war was triggered primarily by trade disputes, including issues over a long-standing problem of low-quality coins manufactured by Nepal for Tibet and political tensions involving Tibetan interference in Nepali affairs. It began with Nepalese Gurkha troops invading Tibet through mountain passes like Kuti and Kerung. They captured key forts such as Chhochyang and Kuti by mid-1788 and fought battles against Tibetan forces. The first war ended with the Treaty of Kerung in June 1789, where Tibet agreed to pay an annual tribute of Rs. 50,000 in silver to Nepal and returned some territories captured during the conflict. The Nepalese Army plundered Tibet, which was a Qing protectorate. The Tibetans sought military help from the Chinese Emperor as well as local Nepalese rulers to resist the invasion. 
1791-1792 The second Nepal-Tibet war took place as a continuation after Tibet stopped paying tribute and tensions flared again. The Qing dynasty, which had a protectorate role over Tibet, intervened militarily with a large force of Manchu, Mongol, and Tibetan troops under General Fuk'anggan. The Qing army repelled the Nepalese troops, pushed them back across the Himalayas, and pursued them into Nepalese territory. The war ended with the Treaty of Betrawati in 1792. Nepal agreed to become a tributary to the Qing emperor and pay tribute every five years, recognizing Qing suzerainty.


 

1792/93 Introduction of the “Golden Urn/Vase” by pressure of the Qing emperor: In the future, official rebirths of high (= politically important) lamas were not anymore to be chosen strictly according to Tibetan traditions. High-ranking lamas were to make a preselection of at least three boys, whose names were written down and put into an urn (a present from the Chinese emperor). Drawing lots decided who would be the official lama child. This procedure was performed e.g. with the nomination of the 10th, 11th and 12th Dalai Lamas as well as with the 8th and the 9th Panchen Lamas.
No term of the 9th Dalai Lama (1805 – 1815). The rumor exists that the 9th to 12th Dalai Lamas all died out of 'unnatural' causes.
No term of the 10th Dalai Lama (1816 – 1837)

 

1828 After the abdication of the Derge-king Tsewang Dorje Rigdzin the civil service was exchanged. The newly appointed civil servants suppressed the nomads through extreme taxes and cruelties. The resulting riots ended in a complete confiscation of all the families’ possessions in Ronggyab.

1838 No term of the 11th Dalai Lama (1838 – 1856)



 

1863 – 1865 During the 19th century, the opposition between Central Tibet (where the Gelugpas were politically predominant) and the Eastern Tibet province Kham became stronger. The Karma Kagyü Lineage had a difficult standing in Central Tibet during the 18th and 19th century - especially after both the 12th Karmapa and the 8th Sharmarpa had died in China. In Kham there were monasteries of the Kagyüs, Nyingmas and at some places also from the Sakyas. The Gelugpa Lineage was hardly represented there.

The great 8th Situpa Chökyi Nyungne (1700 - 1774) had founded the Palpung monastery in the 1720s. Along with Tsurphu, it became the most important center of the Karma Kagyü transmission, well known amongst others of the Karma Gadri school of painting and both its significant printing works and library. In Palpung, more exactly at a hermitage above the monastery, the famous Rimay-master Jamgön Kongtrul Lodrö Thaye (1813 - 1899) settled down there.

During that time Gönpo Namgyal from the remote region Nyarong set himself up as a rebel-leader and brought some regions of Eastern-Tibet under his control. Also, the small kingdom of Derge belonged to it, where the famous monastery Palpung was located. The queen of Derge and two of her sons were kidnapped by the guerillas. Also, the young 10th Situpa was kidnapped. When the rebel-leader finally brought the trading-route between Tibet and China under his control, the central government followed an appeal for help from Derge in 1863, intervened and defeated Gönpo Namgyal in 1865. Thus, Lhasa was mainly under control of Eastern Tibet again. The renowned Jamgön Kongtrul was engaged, and he actually supported the intervention from Central Tibet. In turn, he succeeded that the status of the monasteries were not touched in this region and none of them was converted into Gelugpa-places. Not only spiritually but also diplomatically they contributed in a high degree so that the variety within the Tibetan Buddhism was maintained. 1874 Jamgön Kongtrul had to leave Palpung due to several factors related to political and religious tensions in the region. He used the time for traveling, collecting and passing on empowerments. He returned in 1866.

No term of the 12th Dalai Lama (1856– 1875).

 

1878 – 1933  Thubten Gyatso, the 13th Dalai Lama (1876 – 1933) was enthroned in 1879, in 1895 was introduced into his worldly functions. His reign marked significant political and social changes in Tibet. He introduced postal services, telegraph lines, currency notes and coins. He sent students abroad for education and established small industries and hydroelectric plants. He fled Tibet twice due to foreign invasions—first to Mongolia during British advances in 1904 and later to India during Chinese incursions in 1910. After the fall of the Manchu dynasty in 1911, he expelled remaining Chinese forces from Tibet. On February 13, 1913, he issued a proclamation reaffirming Tibet's independence. Thubten Gyatso's leadership brought stability and prosperity to Tibet during his reign. His efforts to modernize the country while preserving its cultural identity left a lasting impact. He passed away on December 17, 1933. The regent resigned. During Dalai Lama's office a lot of intrigues happened behind his back. 

 

1896 - 1910 Clashes between local chieftains, sometimes supported by Chinese troops, occurred regularly in Eastern Tibet.  The frequent turmoils in Kham had also its cause because the Khampas wanted to become more independent of the Tibetan central government. The tendency to arrange with the Chinese, was stronger in Lhasa where Chinese troops were deployed. At the same time the increasing weakness and instability of the Chinese emperor's state became noticeable.



 

1903 The new Amban (representative of the Chinese emperor) made remarks that too many monks are in the monasteries, they better should work in agriculture. Monks killed the Amban and his escort. Chinese soldiers took revenge and killed more than 1500 monks and laymen.

1904 Invasion of British troops into Tibet (Francis Younghusband – his soldiers killed ~ 500 Tibetan soldiers at Gyantse). The 13th Dalai Lama escaped to Mongolia in 1904/05 when the British troops came. Having returned to Lhasa by the end of 1909, he left Tibet again only two months later to Darjeeling/Kalimpong in 1910.


 

Further Information

Chökyi Jungnay: “The Eighth Situpa on the Third Karmapa's Mahamudra Prayer, Introduction by Venerable Khenchen Trangu Rinpoche”, Translation by Lama Sherab Dorje, Snow Lion Publications Ithaca, New York Boulder, Colorado, 2nd edition 2004

The Princeton Dictionary of Buddhism: p. 189, Princeton Universtity Press, 2014

https://www.druponrinpoche.org/en/lineage/kagyu-lineage/chokyi-jungne-8th-situpa/

https://www.palpung.org/english/lineage/tai_8.htm

https://leksheyling.net/pages/english/Lineages/KagyuGoldenrosary/032_8th-Situ_si-tu-chos-kyi-%27byung-gnas.htm